Impressions of Robben Island

 

Robben Island, like Stonehenge, the Taj Mahal and Yellowstone National Park, is a World Heritage Site. It gets its name from the Dutch word for the seals that visit its coast. African black oystercatchers nest on its shore. But its World Heritage status comes from neither its wild life nor its architecture, much of which is forbidding. On this small island, little over a mile long, Nelson Mandela spent 18 of his 27 years in captivity.

 

Recently we had a guided tour, crossing to the island by ferry and looking back on Cape Town’s fine waterfront and Table Mountain. For many years the island was used as a place of isolation for lepers, the mentally ill and, from the time of the first European colonists in the 17th century, as a prison. Mandela was sent to the island for a few weeks in the early 1960’s. By 1964, when he began his life sentence, the prison was run on strict apartheid lines: all the warders were white and all prisoners non­white.

 

We were shown round the maximum security prison by a former political prisoner who spoke eloquently of his experiences. He told us about the many petty and demeaning regulations, for example how a prisoner’s classification as black or coloured determined his daily ration of sugar. Prisoners were divided into different categories (A to D) with those in D category (like Mandela) allowed to receive only 2 family visits per year, to receive 2 letters per year and to send 2 letters (of 500 words) per year. All letters (incoming and outgoing) were censored by the guards, who used scissors to cut out anything deemed unsuitable. Sometimes the opening and closing greetings were all that remained after censorship, which our guide described vividly as a form of mental torture. It preyed on your mind that important family news was being deliberately withheld. He said that once the prison governor had not told a man that his father had died until it was too late for him to attend his funeral. Mandela was not allowed to attend his mother’s funeral.

 

The cells that had housed political prisoners were bleak. Each measured 2 x 2½   metres. Although I could envisage these dimensions in the abstract, it still brought it home to me to see Mandela’s cell and slops bucket and to imagine a man trying to sleep on the concrete floor with only thin mats and few blankets. Through a barred window one looked out on a courtyard surrounded by a high wall.

 

The prisoners endured a harsh routine. Woken at 5.30, they slopped out at 6.45 before being given breakfast in their cells. After an inspection they had to sit on the ground in the courtyard and hammer stones until lunch at noon, then continue breaking stones until 4pm. After a few months, work in the courtyard was replaced by hard labour in the lime quarry. We saw the quarry and the dazzling white of the lime, which (for the first 3 years) they had to dig out with no goggles to protect their eyes from the glare and (at best) handkerchiefs to prevent them inhaling the fine dust. Armed prison guards could survey their every movement from the rim of the quarry. A tiny cave had to serve as both lavatory and eating place.

 

Later conditions eased, partly through protests by the prisoners themselves - refusal to work, go-slows and, as a desperate last measure, hunger strikes - and partly through mounting international pressure on the apartheid regime. They were allowed to talk as they worked and, especially at meal times, the quarry became a place of political discussion. Mandela conceived the idea of the prison becoming a place of study, even a university. In the quarry they taught each other. A basic aim was that nobody should leave unable to read and some guards were glad to take advantage of these classes. Prisoners who behaved were allowed to study in their cells, but such study was always a privilege, never a right. Several prisoners gained university degrees through study on the island. By the time that our guide was imprisoned (from 1986 to the early 1990’s when the last political prisoners were released) the men were allowed to listen to the radio, read newspapers and to play tennis and basketball.

 

After their release many former political prisoners revisited the island together. Mandela was the first to leave the quarry and, as he did so, he placed a stone on the ground. Others followed suit and we saw the cairn of stones that was formed that day, each one representing a prisoner who had probably laboured there for years.

 

Warders too were victims of the apartheid system and their lives were distorted by it. Some of the warders were brutal, though our guide stressed that others had shown humanity. Someone asked whether he was able to forgive his captors and the police who had assaulted him, leaving a scar on his nose. “Yes”, he said, “I have done.” As we walked to the ferry to return to Cape Town, he pointed to a passing vehicle. “In the passenger’s seat of that car is a former guard. We are both guides now.”

 

Our few hours on the island were a most memorable and deeply moving experience. Robben Island was a place of oppression, but its prison buildings symbolize (in the words of its citation as a World Heritage Site) “the triumph of the human spirit”. You can read more about Nelson Mandela in his autobiography Long Walk to Freedom that is based on a manuscript smuggled out from the island.

Robin McLean

February 2003